Bookkeeper vs accountant vs CPA: which one does your Canadian business need?
For small business owners deciding who to hire. What a bookkeeper, an accountant, and a CPA each do, which of those titles the law protects, the work only a licensed CPA can sign, and how to tell which one your business needs this year.
What is the difference between a bookkeeper, an accountant, and a CPA?
A landscaping company in Guelph has six staff, a line of credit up for renewal, and a bank asking for year-end financial statements "prepared by an accountant." The bookkeeper who reconciles its accounts every month says year-end statements are not her job. The man who files the corporate tax return says he is an accountant, though not a CPA, and asks what kind of statements the bank means. Each of them is right, and the owner still does not know who to call.
- A bookkeeper records what happened. Every sale, bill, payroll run, and bank transaction goes into the books, and each account is matched to its statement every month.
- An accountant takes those records and turns them into year-end financial statements, tax returns, and advice on what the numbers mean.
- A CPA (Chartered Professional Accountant) is an accountant whose designation is protected by provincial law. In Ontario, only a CPA who also holds a public accounting licence can do an audit or a review engagement that a bank or an investor will rely on.
Most small businesses need a bookkeeper and an accountant. Fewer need the licence than the bank's wording suggests. The rules below are Ontario's. Other provinces regulate the CPA designation and public accounting through their own laws and their own CPA bodies, and the details differ, so treat this as general information and check your own province before you rely on it.
What does a bookkeeper do?
Bookkeeping is the running record of the business, kept daily or weekly and closed monthly. A bookkeeper usually:
- records sales, sends invoices, and enters bills as they arrive;
- codes every bank and credit card transaction to the right account;
- reconciles each bank and card account to its statement at month end;
- runs payroll, or records the payroll provider's journal;
- pulls together the sales and tax figures for the GST/HST return;
- keeps the receipt or invoice behind each entry.
The CRA generally expects you to keep your records and supporting documents for six years from the end of the last tax year they relate to. A bookkeeper who attaches the receipt to the transaction is building that file as the year goes.
Nobody in Ontario needs a licence to keep books. The Public Accounting Act names bookkeeping, and installing bookkeeping systems, as work a person can do without one. So the title tells you nothing about training. Some bookkeepers have an accounting diploma and a decade in the job, and some started last spring.
Bookkeeping is also the cheaper hour. Job Bank's wage figures, from its November 19, 2025 update, put the median bookkeeper in Canada at $28.02 an hour, against $40.36 for an accountant. A firm bills more than either wage, and the gap between the two roles usually carries through to what you pay. It usually makes sense to have the bookkeeper do the monthly volume and to pay accountant rates only for the year-end work.
What does an accountant do that a bookkeeper does not?
An accountant starts where the monthly books stop. At year end, that usually means:
- the adjusting entries the monthly books do not carry, such as amortization on equipment, bills that belong to the year but arrived after it, and the owner's shareholder loan balance;
- the balance sheet, income statement, and notes that make up the financial statements;
- the corporate income tax return (the T2), which is due within six months of the end of the company's tax year;
- the planning that has to happen before the year closes, such as how the owner is paid.
A good accountant also reads the books with a skeptical eye. If a new truck was coded to repairs, or the owner's personal phone bill to the company, the year end is where it should get caught.
In Ontario, "accountant" on its own is not a protected title. The Chartered Professional Accountants of Ontario Act, 2017 says it does not interfere with the right of someone who is not a member of CPA Ontario to practise as an accountant. The person doing your year end may be a CPA, may have an accounting degree and no designation, or may have neither, and the law allows all three.
What makes someone a CPA?
CPA stands for Chartered Professional Accountant. Ontario's three older accounting bodies, for chartered accountants (CA), certified management accountants (CMA), and certified general accountants (CGA), were merged into one, CPA Ontario. That is why you still see some accountants sign as "CPA, CA."
Unlike "accountant," the CPA title is protected. Only a member of CPA Ontario may use the designation or the initials, hold themselves out as a Chartered Professional Accountant, or practise as one, and the older CA, CMA, and CGA titles are covered the same way. Using them without membership is an offence, with a fine of up to $10,000 for a first conviction and up to $25,000 for each one after that.
A CPA has met the profession's education, exam, and experience requirements, and answers to CPA Ontario for how they work. You can check the claim yourself. CPA Ontario's public directories let you look a person up by name. The member directory lists members in good standing and members under suspension, and a separate directory lists public accounting licences, including people who no longer hold one. Read the status on the listing, and call CPA Ontario if you need it confirmed.
What can only a licensed CPA do?
Ontario's Public Accounting Act, 2004 reserves one kind of work for licensed public accountants. It calls that work public accounting, and it covers two services done independently of the business they are for:
- assurance engagements, including an audit or a review engagement, on financial statements a third party can reasonably be expected to rely on;
- compilations a third party is expected to rely on, unless the compilation carries a notice in the prescribed form saying any assurance is limited to the accuracy of the computations.
To hold the licence, you have to be a member of CPA Ontario. So every licensed public accountant in Ontario is a CPA, but the CPA designation does not come with the licence. Practising public accounting without one carries a fine of up to $25,000 for a first offence and up to $50,000 for any after that.
The three levels of year-end statements
This is where the bank's wording matters. Year-end statements come with three levels of assurance, and each one generally costs more than the one before.
- In a compilation, an accountant puts your statements together from your records and gives no assurance on them. Many small private companies file their T2 from compiled statements, and many lenders accept them for smaller loans. With the prescribed notice, a compilation is not public accounting, and an accountant without a designation can prepare one.
- In a review engagement, the accountant asks questions and analyzes the numbers, enough to say whether anything suggests the statements are materially wrong. It gives limited assurance, and in Ontario it takes a licence.
- In an audit, the auditor tests the evidence behind the numbers and gives an opinion on whether the statements are presented fairly. It gives the most assurance, costs the most, and takes a licence.
Your corporate tax return asks about this directly. Schedule 141 goes in with the financial information on a T2 filed using the GIFI (the CRA's standard codes for each line of the financial statements). Among its questions, it asks whether the person primarily involved with the statements has a professional designation in accounting, and whether they are connected to the corporation. It then asks what kind of work was done on the statements. The choices include an auditor's report, a review engagement report, a compilation engagement, accounting services, and bookkeeping services.
Reading "accountant-prepared statements" in a renewal letter and hiring for year end without asking what the bank means. The owner pays for a review engagement the bank never needed, or hands over a compilation when the loan agreement called for a review.
Read the reporting clause in the loan agreement, or ask the account manager to put the level they need in writing, before you hire anyone for the year end.
Does the person doing my taxes need to be a CPA?
No. The Public Accounting Act lets anyone prepare financial statements as part of a tax return without a licence, as long as they offer no opinion on them independent of the taxpayer.
The CRA's own rule for paid preparers is about how returns are filed. A tax preparer who accepts payment to prepare more than five returns of one kind in a calendar year has to file those returns electronically. The rule counts each kind on its own: T1 returns (the personal income tax and benefit return), T2 returns, and T3 returns (the return a trust files). An employee who prepares returns as part of their job is not a tax preparer under the rule. Each return filed on paper instead can cost the preparer a penalty of $25 for a T1 or T3 and $100 for a T2.
Whoever prepares it, the return is your company's, so ask who does the work, whether they hold a designation, and who looks at it before it is filed.
Which one does my business need?
Match yourself to the closest scenario.
Scenario A. A sole proprietor with one bank account, no staff, and a few dozen transactions a month. Bookkeeping software and an hour or two a month, or a bookkeeper for a few hours. At tax time, an accountant or a tax preparer for your personal return. Nothing in this picture needs a licence.
Scenario B. An incorporated business, registered for GST/HST, with staff on payroll. A bookkeeper every month, and an accountant at year end for compiled statements and the T2. This is where a designation starts to earn its fee. The year-end entries, the T2, payroll, and how the owner is paid all affect each other, and a mistake in one shows up in the others. We would want a CPA on this year end.
Scenario C. A lender's covenant (a condition written into your loan agreement) or an investor asks for reviewed or audited statements. You need a licensed public accountant for that engagement, on top of whoever keeps your books. The Act describes the work as done independently of the business, and the profession's independence rules can limit what else the same firm does for you. Ask before you hire one firm for both.
Ask what "accountant-prepared" means to them. For many small loans it means compiled statements. A covenant that says "reviewed" or "audited" means the licence.
You probably already know, but your bookkeeper and your accountant work best as a relay. Books that are reconciled every month make the year end shorter and cheaper, and our monthly close rhythm is how that habit works in practice. If the open question is whether to hire a bookkeeper or use a firm, the comparison of hiring, outsourcing, and doing it yourself covers what each costs. See what our bookkeeping service covers month to month, and where Canadian tax picks it up at year end.
What is the difference between a bookkeeper, an accountant, and a CPA in Canada?
A bookkeeper records and reconciles the day-to-day transactions, an accountant turns those records into financial statements and tax returns, and a CPA is an accountant whose designation provincial law protects; in Ontario, only a CPA who also holds a public accounting licence can do an audit or review engagement that a third party will rely on.
| Role | Typical work | Protected title in Ontario | Audit or review for a bank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bookkeeper | Transactions, reconciliations, invoices, payroll entries | No | No |
| Accountant | Year-end entries, compiled statements, tax returns | No | No |
| CPA | An accountant's work, as a member of CPA Ontario | Yes | Only with a licence |
| CPA with a public accounting licence | All of the above, plus audits and review engagements | Yes | Yes |
Sources and further reading
- Where to keep your records and for how long and when to file your corporation income tax return (CRA)
- Mandatory electronic filing for tax preparers and Guide RC4088, General Index of Financial Information, including Schedule 141 (CRA)
- Public Accounting Act, 2004 and Chartered Professional Accountants of Ontario Act, 2017 (Ontario e-Laws)
- Job Bank wages for a bookkeeper and an accountant in Canada (Government of Canada)
Flat monthly pricing for books that are ready at year end.
We keep the books reconciled every month, so the year end begins from numbers that already tie out. See what our bookkeeping service covers and where Canadian tax picks it up, then book a free books review and we will look at what your filings and your lender ask of your books today.
Bookkeeping plans start at $299 Starter and $499 Growth. Those are base prices and vary with complexity.
